Celebrate Father's Day around the grill with 20% OFF our premium 10 PK New York Strip Steaks!

How To Make Raw Butter

July 25, 2019 • 0 comments

How To Make Raw Butter



I don't really have a 'recipe' for making butter, but here are my "how-to steps" to make it...

  1. Let the raw milk set in the refrigerator undisturbed for at least half a day to make sure that all the cream has risen to the top.
  2. Use a (clean) turkey baster to draw the cream off the top of the jug. Another way that works: Ahead of time, pour the milk into a clear container, (so you can see the cream line when it forms) let it set for half a day in the fridge and skim the cream off the top with a large spoon or dipper. Be sure not to mix the milk with the cream as you draw it off.
  3. Let the newly separated cream set out at room temperature for two or three hours. (warm cream will form butter more quickly)
  4. Pour the cream into your blender and blend for about five minutes. You may hear the blender work harder as the butter begins to form. Blend slowly and stop when the butter separates into a golden ball. If you continue to blend, it will just keep cutting the butter into little pieces.
  5. Remove the butter and any small pieces that are floating in the buttermilk with a slotted spoon or clean hands. The butter milk can be used to fertilize your house or garden plants. Just pour a ½ pint or so at the base of the roots. They are nourished by milk too!
  6. Rinse the butter under cold running water while squeezing and kneading the butter with your hands. This step is important to remove all the buttermilk. If the buttermilk is not removed sufficiently the butter will turn rancid quicker. Rancid butter is not dangerous, but many Americans are not accustomed to the ripe taste. If you are from Europe and are accustomed to cultured butter, you might like the cheesy flavor of slightly rancid butter.
  7. For salted butter, add salt to taste. Work the salt in with your hands.
  8. To maintain freshness, keep the raw butter refrigerated. You can leave one day’s amount out at room temperature for easy spreading, but refrigerate leftovers. If you leave it out too long and it starts to taste strong, remember, it is not turning dangerous. The tremendous probiotics and enzymes are just working to culture it further.
  9. Do Not Forget: Order an extra gallon or so of raw milk if you'd like to make butter this week!



  • Butter yields vary depending on the skill and experience of the butter maker.
  • 1 gallon of milk will usually yield 1 to 1.5 pint of cream.
  • The cream will churn to approx. 1/3 to ½ lb of butter.
  • The above info is for our raw cow milk only. Goat butter is a totally different story and we have no experience with that. I’m not even sure if it is possible since the cream does not rise with goat milk.

Hands-on Butter Making with your Children

As a child, I remember shaking cream in jars to make butter. We always thought it was fun... especially eating the fresh butter at the end. 😋

A few days ago I showed Andre and Clara how to do it. I gave them each a jar of cream and it wasn't long until we had butter. They were impressed! Here is a really simple hands-on method.

  • Let the raw cream thaw / warm up to room temp (this is not a requirement, but it does help the butter to form faster)
  • Pour cream into another container with a lid—we simply pour the 12 oz. bottle into a pint jar (16 oz.) so there is room to shake the cream
  • Shake until butter clumps have formed (and don't seem to be continuing to grow). It only takes a few minutes depending on how vigorously you shake. Feel free to take as many breaks as you want. No need to shake continuously.

There you have it—fresh raw butter!

All you really need to do after this is 1) rinse it with cold water to get the last of the buttermilk out... then 2) salt to taste.

And of course, if you need Raw Cream, you know where to get it. We even have a 5-pack savings option so the whole family can make butter together. :)

Your Farmer,


~5th generation on the farm

Click to see our farm 10 Core Values

If you're near PA we can help you get started making your own Raw Butter with Family Cow Grass-fed Milk!

We've served thousands of happy families since 2008... and Raw Milk is just the beginning. You'll also get nutrient-dense foods like truly pastured soy-free Chicken, 100% Grass-fed Beef, Pastured Pork, Wild Caught Salmon, and nourishing bone broths recommended by Sally Fallon.

It's our goal to bring you clean, high integrity foods you can eat with confidence at every meal. Everything we sell is Chemical-Free, GMO-Free, Antibiotic-Free, Soy-Free, Humanely Raised and Truly Pastured.

P.S. Don't be fooled by Industrial Organics in the grocery store. Source your foods directly from a farmer you know and trust.

Chicken Fried Steak
March 8, 2024 • 0 comments